Strangely enough, Miss Norton never proved "popular" enough to win Locus Polls. It doesn't mean, though, that her name never appeared in them. Below's a list of all the nominations Ms. Norton received since 1973. I reckon that requires no further comment.
| Year | Category | Place | For |
| 1973 | All-Time Favourite Author | 16 | Andre Norton |
| 1978 | Fantasy Novel | 12 | Trey of Swords |
| 1981 | Single Author Collection | 15 | Lore of the Witch World |
| 1982 | Fantasy Novel | 8 | Horn Crown |
| 1982 | Fantasy Novel | 19 | Gryphon in Glory |
| 1984 | Fantasy Novel | 24 | 'Ware Hawk! |
| 1987 | All-Time Fantasy Novel | 31 | Witch World |
| 1987 | All-Time Fantasy Novelist | 22 | Andre Norton |
| 1987 | All-Time Novelist (combined SF&F) | 36 | Andre Norton |
| 1988 | All-Time Favourite Author | 12 | Andre Norton |
| 1988 | Anthology | 9 | Tales of The Witch World |
| 1990 | Collection | 15 | Wizards' Worlds |